regmail.me vs SimpleLogin and Addy
SimpleLogin and Addy can send and reply through unlimited aliases. regmail.me only receives. Compare before you settle on an alias strategy.
What do SimpleLogin and Addy actually do?
SimpleLogin and Addy are alias services: you generate a unique address per site, mail sent to it forwards into your real inbox, and you can reply from that alias without ever revealing your real address to the person you are writing to. Both offer browser extensions that generate an alias right on a signup form.
On their paid plans, both support a large or unlimited number of aliases, so a different address per account is realistic to maintain long term.
What does regmail.me do instead?
regmail.me creates a standalone mailbox, not a forwarding alias. You sign in with Google, claim an address, and mail arrives directly in it rather than being relayed into another inbox. There is no reply path at all, forwarded or otherwise.
The free tier gives one mailbox per account; going further draws on Energy, the site’s prepaid unit.
Where do SimpleLogin and Addy actually win?
If you need to reply as the alias, or you want a large number of aliases centrally managed with one dashboard, both tools do this and regmail.me does not. Sending is core to how they work, not an add-on.
They also let you disable a single leaked alias without touching any of your other addresses, which limits the damage from one site’s data breach far better than reusing the same address everywhere.
Where does regmail.me fit better?
regmail.me needs only a Google account and no browser extension or forwarding setup. If you specifically want an address that never forwards anywhere and never sends, for something like an automated test or a one-off signup you plan to check occasionally, that separation is simpler with a standalone mailbox than with a forwarding alias tied to your main inbox.
How do the two compare?
| SimpleLogin / Addy | regmail.me | |
|---|---|---|
| Can send or reply through the alias | Yes | No |
| Where mail lands | Forwards into your real inbox | Its own separate mailbox |
| Number of aliases | Large or unlimited on paid plans | 1 free, more via Energy |
| Setup | Account plus browser extension | Google sign in only |
| Can disable one address without affecting others | Yes | Yes, delete or stop using that mailbox |
| Cost to start | Free tier with limits, paid plans for more | Free, limits apply |
The common thread across every alias tool, including regmail.me, is that a shut down service takes your addresses with it. For anything you would be upset to lose access to, keep at least one recovery path on an address you fully control.
Which one should you use?
- Need to reply from the alias itself: SimpleLogin or Addy
- Want many aliases centrally managed with one-click disable: SimpleLogin or Addy
- Want a standalone mailbox with no forwarding and no extension: regmail.me
- Need a receive only address for a script or a single signup: regmail.me
Frequently asked questions
Can I reply to mail through a regmail.me address?
No. regmail.me mailboxes only receive; there is no way to send or reply from one. If replying through the alias matters, SimpleLogin or Addy are built for that.
Do SimpleLogin and Addy cost money?
Both offer a free tier with a limited number of aliases and paid plans that raise or remove that limit. Exact limits and pricing change over time, so check each service’s own site for current terms.
What happens if one of my SimpleLogin or Addy aliases gets spammed?
You can disable that single alias without affecting any of your other addresses or your real inbox, since each one is independent. This is one of the main reasons people use a different alias per site in the first place.
Is a regmail.me mailbox an alias like SimpleLogin?
No, it is a standalone mailbox rather than a forwarding alias. Mail lands directly in it instead of being relayed to another inbox, and there is no reply capability the way an alias service provides.
Get your own receive-only mailbox
Free, permanent, and ready in seconds — no setup required.